Connected swimming pool: your phone monitors the water, but who monitors the probe?

You're at work, about thirty kilometers from home.

Your phone vibrates. A notification tells you that your pool’s pH is starting to rise. You open the app, check the latest measurements, and discover a nice curve that has been rising since morning.

Quite convenient. A few years ago, you probably would have discovered the problem on your way home, with your tape box in hand.

Today, a small device placed in the water can monitor several parameters and alert you when something changes. But is it really useful? And most importantly, can these devices save you time from having to maintain your pool?

The answer is interesting. Because there are some differences between the commercial promises and the reality of the garden.

A small probe that monitors your pool day and night

Connected analyzers often resemble small floating objects. You place them in the basin, you connect them to an application, and they start collecting information.

According to the model, they can measure the temperature, pH and the oxidation-reduction potential of water, called ORP or Redox. Some devices also have conductivity sensors, especially to monitor salinity.

This is the principle of equipment such as ICO from Ondilo or EcO from iopool. The data can then be consulted on a phone, sometimes with graphs and recommendations.

For a family pool, that’s already interesting. You can see if the pH changes after a big storm or if the disinfection conditions change during a period of heavy bathing.

But beware of one detail: A connected analyzer does not necessarily measure all the parameters of your water.

The EcO device from iopool, for example, directly measures three main parameters: temperature, pH and redox potential. Other information, such as alkalinity or the amount of stabilizer, may be included in the calculations of its application. However, not all of these are measured directly by probes.

That is a significant difference.

The trap of the number displayed on your phone

Imagine a pool treated with chlorine. Your application indicates a Redox value of 680 millivolts. Everything seems normal. But that doesn’t mean you know the exact concentration of free chlorine in the water.

Redox measures the oxidizing potential of water, which provides information about its disinfecting power. This is not the same thing as a measurement of chlorine concentration.

Ondilo explains that, for example, two basins with comparable chlorine concentrations can have different redox values.

The pH plays an important role in this variation. The higher the pH, the generally lower the disinfectant effectiveness of chlorine. The presence of a stabilizer also influences the interpretation of the measurements.

In practice, a nice green curve on your application does not exempt you from performing additional checks.

The American Centers for Disease Prevention, the CDC, recommend, among other things, regularly measuring the pH and chlorine concentration of the water. Their May 10, 2024 guide recommends a pH range between 7.0 and 7.8 for private pools. This is an American health recommendation, not a French regulatory standard.

The values to be sought must also comply with the instructions of the manufacturers and the treatment used. So keep your analysis kit with you. Even though it seems much less modern than your new connected gadget.

Monitoring water and treating water: two different things

This is probably the most important distinction. A connected probe monitors your pool. An automatic control system can act on certain parameters.

Let's take an example. Your analyzer detects that the pH is increasing. It sends you a notification. It's up to you to verify the measurement and decide if a correction is necessary.

With an automatic pH regulator properly installed, the equipment can dose the correct corrector product according to the measurements and parameters defined.

Some systems go even further. The manufacturer Bayrol offers equipment capable of regulating pH and injecting disinfectant, but also of controlling certain additional equipment. This is the case with its Automatic Cl-pH system, which is paired with various control options.

On paper, it’s appealing. You control the settings less often manually and corrections can be made automatically.

In practice, there are still several things to check. The can of corrective product can be emptied. A probe can become clogged. Equipment can fail. And the settings must be adapted to the basin.

Dosage safeguards must also be provided and the operating conditions of the filtration system must be respected. For systems that automatically inject chemicals, it is better to entrust the installation and adjustments to a competent professional.

The bad surprise: a probe that tells you anything

You installed your analyzer in the spring. For several months, everything works fine. Then one morning, the app announces an astonishingly high pH. You start looking for your bottle of corrector.

Before you pour anything, stop. The probe may simply be misaligned.

Electrochemical probes evolve over time. Their measurements can gradually drift. That is why manufacturers provide for calibration operations using reference solutions.

iopool recommends, for its EcO analyzer, a calibration at the beginning of each season starting from the second year of use.

Ondilo recommends an annual calibration for seasonal use of his ICO device, and two calibrations per year for continuous use.

These frequencies correspond to these specific equipment. They should not be applied automatically to all devices.

Another factor to consider: some probes need to be replaced after a few years. The lifespan depends on the model, the conditions of use, and maintenance.

A connected swimming pool therefore still requires some maintenance. Simply, it’s not always the same thing anymore.

And what if the Wi-Fi doesn’t reach the pool area?

Here’s a much less spectacular problem in commercials. You have a house with thick walls. Your swimming pool is at the bottom of the garden. Between the two is a terrace, a hedge, and maybe a garage. Your phone has difficulty picking up Wi-Fi near the pool.

Then it is necessary to check how the intended analyzer works. Some models communicate directly via Wi-Fi. Others use Bluetooth and require a relay to transmit their measurements remotely.

For its EcO analyzer, iopool recommends bringing the Bluetooth/Wi-Fi relay closer to the pool when communication is poor. The manufacturer also explains that walls, shutters, and covers can reduce the range of the signal.

This is something to check before buying. Because a probe that works perfectly when you are two meters from the pool, but stops transmitting anything as soon as you enter the house, loses some of its appeal.

Some devices temporarily retain their measurements in the event of a disconnection. But this function depends on the model. Before choosing, therefore, see what happens when the internet connection drops.

Can filtering also be automated?

Yes, some equipment allows you to program or control the filtration. For example, you can set operating ranges from an app.

More comprehensive systems can also control the heating or certain electrical appliances. But beware of the savings promises.

Connected filtration does not automatically reduce your bill. It all depends on the pump, its power, the operating times, and how the system is configured.

Let’s take a pump that consumes 750 watts. If it runs for eight hours, it theoretically uses 6 kWh of electricity. If you reduce its operation by one hour, the theoretical savings are 0.75 kWh.

It is a simple electrical calculation, not a recommendation for reducing filtration.

The required duration depends on the water temperature, the number of visitors, the design of the pool and the installed system.

It would therefore be a shame to reduce filtration excessively in order to save a few kilowatt hours and end up with water that is degraded.

We have already detailed these calculations in our article on the electric cost of the pool pump.

An app does not replace regular maintenance

The technology can prevent some problems. It does not remove leaves that have fallen at the bottom of the basin. It does not automatically clean a skimmer basket. And it does not necessarily detect a plumbing system that is starting to leak.

A perfectly balanced water can also contain debris. Conversely, a transparent water is not automatically a properly disinfected water.

Therefore, it is necessary to continue monitoring the equipment and carrying out the necessary maintenance operations.

Our article on the actual time spent maintaining a swimming pool It also makes it easier to understand the tasks that remain indispensable.

The proper use of a connected analyzer is to use it to complement your controls, not to abandon them.

Before buying, look at the cost over several years

When you compare two analyzers, the price listed on the box doesn’t tell the whole story. You also need to consider what will be needed to continue using it.

Does replacing the probes represent an additional expense? Do I need to purchase calibration solutions? Does remote connection require an accessory? Are some of the app’s functions paid for?

And above all, what happens to the device if the manufacturer one day stops maintaining its service? These questions deserve to be asked before ordering.

Computer security also matters. The CNIL recommends, in particular, changing the default passwords for connected devices and securing the Wi-Fi network to which they are connected.

Also consider updates, permissions requested by the application, and the data stored in your account.

A connected pool should make your life easier. Not force you to become the computer administrator of your garden.

So, a gadget or a real good idea?

It all depends on your usage. If you have a small pool that is used a few weeks each summer, a connected analyzer is not necessarily indispensable. A reliable analyzer kit and regular maintenance can perfectly suffice.

However, if you have a swimming pool that is used for several months, or if you are absent frequently, being able to monitor the water’s evolution remotely can be interesting.

The technology mainly allows for detecting certain variations more quickly and maintaining a history of measurements.

And if you subsequently choose an automatic control system, some of the corrections can be made without systematic manual intervention.

But the real progress isn’t never having to worry about your pool again. It’s knowing when it needs you more easily.

The rest of the time, you can enjoy the garden. Provided you keep an eye on the dog. Because he also seems to have decided that this little floating probe deserved a thorough inspection.

Sources and references

  • iopool : Measured parameters, calibration of the EcO analyzer, and Bluetooth/Wi-Fi connection.
  • Ondilo : ICO documentation, Redox interpretation and calibration.
  • CDC – Healthy Swimming : pH and disinfectant control tips (guide dated May 10, 2024).
  • Bayrol Automatic pH and disinfection control devices.
  • CNIL Security recommendations for connected objects.
en_GB