Swimming pool made of steel panels or polystyrene blocks: the kit that really changes the construction site

You have decided to build an underground swimming pool, but not to bring the entire shell into the garden. In the quotes, two expressions appear: steel panels and polystyrene blocks to be filled with concrete. At first glance, the two solutions look like kits. In reality, they are not assembled in the same way at all. And the difference can have an impact on the construction site, handling, and budget.

The panel pool: a structure assembled on site

The principle of industrial panels is quite easy to understand. Elements manufactured in a factory are transported to the site, then assembled to form the walls of the pool. Steel is common, but it is not the only material available: polymers, aluminum, and pre-stressed concrete also exist. The Federation of Pool and Spa Professionals specifically highlights this diversity of modular structures.

Once the panels have been installed and stabilized according to the chosen system, the groundwork, backfilling, sealing, and equipment work are completed. Depending on the technique, the foundation can be made with a slab or a specific structure. This is not a matter of improvisation on the spot: the instructions and technical specifications of the manufacturer are binding.

The advantage is the logistics. It is possible to move several elements instead of transporting a hull in one piece. This is sometimes valuable if your house has a narrow side passage. Be careful with the weight, the dimensions of the rooms, and the space needed for working. The kit arrives in pieces, but the soil for the foundation must always be removed from the garden.

Polystyrene blocks: concrete behind the lightness

The name can mislead. A pool made of polystyrene blocks is not a pool whose walls are simply made of foam. The blocks are joined together to form a permanent framework. The intended reinforcements are installed, and then the concrete is poured. It is the reinforced concrete structure that supports the pool.

Technical guides, such as the technical opinion of the NEOBLOC system, describe this lost form of coffering. The blocks also serve as insulation for the walls, but they do not replace the reinforcement or an appropriate design. The preparation of the foundation, the requirements for the reinforcement and the casting play a decisive role. These are masonry operations, not just the assembly of giant Lego bricks.

The lightness of the blocks simplifies their handling. However, the concrete must be transported, the formwork and reinforcement must be managed, and the quantities of parts to be sealed must be calculated. If a pump truck is needed or appropriate access is required, this must be included in the quote from the outset.

Which one is easiest to install yourself?

The answer depends more on your skills than on the «kit» label. With panels, assembly seems intuitive, but you must respect the geometry, reinforcements, stability during backfilling, and all the assembly instructions. With formwork blocks, handling is simple, but the steelwork and concrete require true expertise.

A rectangular basin measuring six meters by three may seem modest. Yet, a level error at the outset often results in problems when laying the edging. A poorly placed reservation requires repairs. And a hastily dug conduit will be less fun to repair once the terrace is finished.

If you wish to participate in the construction, ask what part of the project the manufacturer allows you to carry out yourself and what operations must be carried out or supervised by a professional. Also check the warranties and exclusions related to self-construction.

Both solutions require well-prepared ground.

Neither steel nor polystyrene requires the soil to be studied. Proper excavation, stable foundations, and the management of external water remain essential. Clay soil, which is compacted or often saturated with water, may require significant adjustments.

We have detailed these precautions in our guide on the construction of a swimming pool on clay-based terrain. The difference between the two systems should never obscure the essential point: if the soil is poorly prepared, the best-chosen structure in the catalogue will not work miracles.

Sealing and finishing: do not confuse the wall with the cladding

A panel or concrete coffered structure does not automatically mean that the basin is watertight as is. Many systems are fitted with a liner or reinforced membrane. The parts to be sealed must be compatible with the chosen finish. Angles, stairs and any benches can also influence the choice of finish.

Polystyrene does not directly accept any type of coating or tile. And with a metal structure, the protection of the panels and assemblies must comply with the manufacturer’s specifications, especially in humid environments. Therefore, compare the complete system: structure, sealing, filtration and finishes.

Which budget should I compare on the quote?

A classic mistake is to compare the price of a lot of panels with that of a pallet of blocks. This doesn’t make much sense. The quote for a pool made of blocks must include concrete, reinforcement, additional formwork, delivery, and casting services. For panels, look at the reinforcements, the preparation of the foundation, the assembly system, and the requirements for backfilling.

In both cases, add landscaping, land drainage, filtration, connections, electricity, cladding, security, and garden restoration. The FPP publishes scale drawings for panel pools, but these are not guaranteed rates for a specific project. The price of the structure is just one line item in the overall budget.

For a broader comparison with conventional shells and concrete, see our comparison of the major pool families.

And to keep the heat?

Polystyrene blocks have an insulating effect that can limit some of the heat exchange through the walls. But it is impossible to derive a universal annual savings. The outdoor temperature, the ground, the covering, the sunlight and especially evaporation all contribute to heat losses.

A pool with insulated walls but left uncovered every night is not necessarily more elegant than another basin that is properly covered. Ask for technical data about the entire system, not a promise of several additional degrees without measurement conditions.

The decision that avoids regrets

Industrialized panels offer true modularity and can simplify the supply process. Formwork blocks provide access to a reinforced concrete structure whose implementation requires masonry organization. Neither of the two is automatically superior.

Before signing, ask for a plan of installation, the details of the tiling, the system manual, the exact list of supplies and the division of responsibilities. Check the terrain, the access points and the total cost. The right pool is not the one whose packaging looks the simplest to unpack. It is the one that can be installed properly and maintained smoothly for a long time.

Sources

Federation of Swimming and Spa Professionals: the types of pools ; Technical review of NEOBLOC, 2023 ; Gedimat: building a swimming pool with polystyrene blocks. The notices specific to each system remain the priority.

en_GB